Amodei 稱 AI 十年內可治癒癌症,醫生持懷疑態度
Amodei Says AI Will Cure Cancer in a Decade. Doctors Are Skeptical
Amodei 在公司發布的一段 42 分鐘 IPO 路演影片中預測,癌症、阿茲海默症、心臟病及精神疾病將在不到十年內成為過去,醫生對此持懷疑態度。討論串中,有人質疑生物實驗和臨牀試驗所需時間能否縮短,也有人認為 AI 可擴大並行研究的規模。
Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Amodei Says AI Will Cure Cancer in a Decade. Doctors Are Skeptical (businessinsider.com) 26 points by robin_reala1 hour ago | hide | past | favorite | 54 comments help
qgin0 minutes ago | next[–] It is very hard to appreciate what exponentials look like in reality. We're on track to have a GPT-3-to-Mythos sized jump in a single year in 2027 or 2028, and its not as if it's going to stop after that year. People have a hard time believing that's going to happen, so they don't believe we will soon "solve" robotics, and so they don't believe robotics can really run an entire biology lab, and so they don't believe we'll have industrical scale data-center sized labs running at high speed 24/7, and so they don't believe that the lab bottleneck can be broken. reply
gensym33 minutes ago | prev | next[–] I've yet to see anyone with expertise in medical research express optimism that AI will cure major diseases like cancer in the next several years. Help us in parts of the research? Sure. But the bottlenecks to medical research are the speed at which the human body does things, and AI isn't going to move that. That also aligns with my (non-medical-expert) intuition. Dario et al are smart enough to know that as well, and they have not presented any compelling counterargument to the speed of biology, which makes me they that they are full of shit and know it. reply
onlyrealcuzzo19 minutes ago | parent | next[–] > I've yet to see anyone with expertise in medical research express optimism that AI will cure major diseases like cancer in the next several years. Depending on "several years" -> it is almost by definition impossible. The trial periods are too long. A lot of major breakthroughs have happened recently and are already in the pipeline, looking promising. There's a lot of progress on this stuff already. Compared to 10-20-30 years ago, a lot of diseases already look "cured", even if they aren't completely. Near immediate death sentences have become 5-10+ years of life expectations, etc. I don't see any reason why AI wouldn't help speed things up in the future. But we won't see any of that for "several years" regardless. reply
lab1414 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] I remember 5 years ago when you couldn't find any programmer that would agree that AI would replace them. Fast forward to today and most programmers haven't opened an IDE in a year or so and hiring freezes all over the place. I'm not saying both cases are equivalent, but A LOT can change in 10 years, specially since the acceleration is compounding over time. Today we're using the absolute worst models that we're going to use in the next 10 years. reply
gensym0 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Ah yes, AI is better than we expected at some things so we should expect it to be good at everything. That's basically the "we're building a god" argument. AI, it turns out, is very, very good at anything that can be verified on computers. We should expect it to continue to improve until it effectively saturates that (i.e., if a problem can be verified on computers in any reasonable amount of time, it's effectively solved). The human body is not something that can be verified on computers. reply
Ungh9 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] My daughter is an expert on the novel non-invasive diagnostic methods side. She states that the bottleneck is that most diagnostic methods and treatments don’t work. And that’s because we have an incomplete understanding of the human body. AI make some small gains but most of the work is a lot of slow, laborious experimentation and measurement which can’t be automated in any reasonable way. Amodei says whatever keeps the money rolling in. reply
qoez26 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] I kinda agree with you. One counter argument I could imagine though is that we make really rapid progress in figuring out low level biology in a first principles predictive way that might make us able to zero in on a solution directly. reply
amelius14 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] We need much better ways to obtain data. Right now an Apple watch cant even read respiratory rate. reply
gensym23 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] I mean, that's the counterargument, I guess. If we accept that AI may become an all-knowing god[1], then we can expect it to do anything. But if that's Dario's argument, he should be making it see how well investors take to the "I believe I'm leading an organization in building a god" approach. [1] I think that's a fair word for something that can simulate the workings of the physical world from first principles reply
0o7775 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] >I've yet to see anyone with expertise in medical research express optimism that AI will cure major diseases like cancer in the next several years It's crazy how AI has completely reversed who is technology optimistic and who is not. A 60-year-old immigrant medical researcher thinks we live in the most exciting time in history and that all major diseases will be cured within a decade. A 29-year-old American zillennial genderfluid medical researcher thinks Dario and Sam Altman are demonic creatures, worse than the devil himself. How did this happen? reply
antonvs23 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] > Dario et al are smart enough to know that as well Maybe, or maybe someone needs to send him this comic: https://phdcomics.com/comics/archive.php?comicid=1162 reply
credit_guy8 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Actually that comic strenghtens the case for AI. AI is able to work on solving one million problems in parallel. Let’s say it only solves 1000 out of 1000000. I’ll take that. Sure, no cure for Cancer, but cures for one thosand types of cancer are still good. Because there is no hard wall saying it’s 1000 and then stop. reply
gensym14 minutes ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] Thanks for sending that. As someone who's in the stage of life where I've lost several people to cancer and will surely lose more, that comic hit me hard. And that makes it more enraging to see the cultists and charlatans running the AI labs using the heartbreak so many people experience because of it as a way to accumulate vast amounts of power. reply
jstummbillig14 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] > I've yet to see anyone with expertise in medical research I mean... that's literally Amodei. But anywho. We just went through this with coding: We are setting up a silly strawman, that will be goal posted to the end of the world. I am relatively certain Amodei does not literally mean "Will you flip AI on, go to sleep, and get a "cancer" pill at your door some day x in the future, all just AI?". Yes, it will involve humans. It's what AI enables, in combination what exists. This might also include changes in regulation (which to me seems like the bottleneck, much more so than speed of the human body). reply
ocius20 minutes ago | prev | next[–] I don't actually think that he's overselling that much. Of course there is no guarantee that all these illnesses will be fixed, but imagine how much more progress can be made if we set up one million automated wetlabs performing research on these sicknesses. I had an agent (irony) estimate that there are around 100k such labs around right now, and these labs are not used around the clock. So 1 Mio automated wetlabs count more like 3 Mio conventional wetlabs. If we now factor in that current models already have much better capabilities to access existing knowledge, and that they may in fact be(come) smarter than the average researcher, that factor increases. reply
aqme2833 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Genuinely curious-- if we eliminate cancer, dementia, and heart disease, what exactly will there be left to die of in old age? reply
robin_reala2 minutes ago | parent | next[–] The climate catastrophe, and the associated conflict and natural disasters. reply
gensym29 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] I am curious as well - my mental model is that cellular damage is going to accumulate throughout the body, so if you can keep the heart going, the liver might fail, etc, etc. It is worth noting that of the 3 things you listed, none are a single disease. They're all descriptions of a wide range of conditions, and that aligns with my understanding of aging in general: so much stuff goes wrong that rather than describe the individual source, we describe its effects. reply
jvanderbot23 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] I'm cautiously optimistic on the limited version of these claims. "Cure" probably means "If we find it quickly enough we can eliminate it", but after some time, you'll see popup fast moving cancers everywhere. Curing certain kinds of cancer would be a nobel winning prize, but it doesn't eliminate all cancers, either. Cardiovascular disease like athlerosclerois have been proposed as being curable. I suspect "dementia/alzheimers" is like cancer - many separate kinds/issues, and we'll eliminate some but not all. reply
Maken16 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Total organ failure. Even if you can cure any individual illness, eventually your body would accumulate enough imperfections due to cellular replication that a unstoppable collapse becomes more and more likely. reply
patall21 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Probably really just brain decline, if you can grow new cells and organs without having to care about cancer. And even there, technology may be able to replace senescent cells at some point. But nobody really knows as even (multicellular, animal) model organisms cannot be kept alive forever today. reply
uptrails17 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] > Probably really just brain decline So, dementia? reply
mrieck14 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] I don't see why anyone would focus on those diseases instead of curing old age. If you don't get old, you don't get any of those diseases. reply
victorbjorklund17 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Lots of things in the body just stops function correctly at some point. Some old people today just die peacefully in their sleep without it being cancer or heart dicease. reply
qgin13 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Those are almost all heart failure or heart attack reply
kashunstva26 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] > what exactly will there be left to die of in old age? Claude will cure old age too, of course. reply
manmal30 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Eventually, fatal injuries get everyone. I read a stat years ago that it can take 500 years. reply
patall20 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] But that is not dying of old age. reply
smoe26 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Once you turn 160, Claude will have you sent to the Near-Death Star. reply
vlyan12 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] accumulated errors in DNA replication. telomere shortening. whatever other things cause aging. we could eliminate all disease, but without solving senescence itself I don't think it's possible to achieve even 200 year lifespans. by 70, even the most blessed of us begin to rapidly fall apart. mind upload is far more plausible than fixing the janky meat machines we inhabit. reply
qgin9 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] If you eliminate all disease, by definition things aren't falling apart. reply
gizajob26 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Boredom. reply
gnabgib11 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Related: Silicon Valley Promises AI Will Cure Disease. Drugmaker CEOs Aren't Buying It (98 points, 4 days ago, 131 comments) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=50415817 reply
fridder25 minutes ago | prev | next[–] This makes me very angry because it falls into the popular trope about cancer being a single thing to "cure". reply
ocius17 minutes ago | parent | next[–] While all cancers are different, there are also underlying mechanisms that are similar and thus may enable a common cure. In the most extreme sense, think nano robots that cut out affected cells. reply
abirch15 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] Exactly, cancer is phenotypic of many diseases and illnesses. Science has cured some cancers by simple vaccines. reply
vb-844817 minutes ago | parent | prev | next[–] I'd bet that it's intentional: if they manage to find a cure only for a specific type of cancer and condition they can still claim that they succeed. reply
FLeXMurphy14 minutes ago | prev | next[–] I really expected better arguments to be put forth by the community, however that hasn't really happened yet. Across the few HN threads this has popped up, the general stance is: "In other fields [coding, math] the experts said Amodei was wrong. He proved to be right. In this field experts are saying Amodei is wrong, therefore he will be proven to be right." That's as simple of a summary as I can given without getting into the details, which are irrelevant and devolve into nit-picking regarding specific wording used (can vs. will), who said and what was really said (or was not said), and so on. To me, that argument is not good enough. I would like to hear something a bit more step-by-step as to why people think he is right or wrong that's beyond mere "because he said so" takes. reply
sandworm10139 minutes ago | prev | next[–] The actual quote is far worse than the title: >> In a 42-minute IPO roadshow video the company released on Tuesday, Amodei made the audacious prediction that "cancer, Alzheimer's, heart disease, mental illness — these will be relics of the past in, I think, less than a decade." Mental illness? I'm sure that will be worked out exactly a day after AI-induced psychosis stops being a thing. Question: Without heart disease, cancer and Alzheimer's, what will kill us? It cannot all be shark attacks and avalanches. What new horrible diseases will step up to be big killers in the future? reply
BugsJustFindMe32 minutes ago | parent | next[–] AI-induced psychosis is likely just AI-exposed latent psychosis. In that light the AI could be said to be getting you closer to the cure by revealing the silent disease. You can't treat what you can't see! I'm being semi-serious. reply
kashunstva27 minutes ago | prev | next[–] > cure cancer Which one? All of them? The mechanisms of neoplastic development and growth are protean. If his prediction is based on aspirations of finding a common pathway, I’m afraid it will be unrealized. I share his enthusiasm for assisted drug development and so forth; but let’s be realistic. Besides, doesn’t his company have an upcoming IPO? I guess it’s a fine time for unbridled optimism then, isn’t it? reply
misnome24 minutes ago | parent | next[–] I don't think anyone making such claims actually knows what cancer is. I think they think it's just a single thing, like a virus. > I guess it’s a fine time for unbridled optimism then, isn’t it? To be fair, they've kept up this fairy-tale optimism most of the way through reply
tim-projects32 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Stock market goes up ”It's literally too dangerous for us to release" Stock market goes down "Ai will cure cancer everyone!" reply
estearum27 minutes ago | parent | next[–] Whatever your opinion on whether we're there right now, there is nothing contradictory about this. The entire point of AI is that it is/can be/will be (at the limit) incredibly powerful. That power can be used for good or bad things. reply
gavinh10 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Is "curing cancer" even well-defined? Aren't some cancers driven by bacterial infection? AI is going to cure all current and future causes of cancer? reply
VBprogrammer31 minutes ago | prev | next[–] I wonder how Elizabeth Holmes is doing these days. reply
Maken13 minutes ago | parent | next[–] She's probably blaming bad timing. Theranos nowadays would be just another AI startup. reply
unpleasurable12 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Full Self Cure reply
baggachipz34 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Fill that bag up to the brim before dumping it on public investors. Looks like everyone's adopting the Elon Prediction Model. reply
shaolinspirit15 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Billionaires leveraging capital to live forever reply
phillennium29 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Here's a more correct title: "One person (who doesn't know the future but has a financial incentive to promise golden age) promises golden age. Other people (who also don't know the future but don't want to lose their jobs) predict that they won't lose their jobs. Both sides can be utterly wrong, so we spend our time in vain here". reply
vivzkestrel31 minutes ago | prev[–] wake me up when it can cure death reply
shaolinspirit14 minutes ago | parent | next[–] just one more agent orchestration framework and I'm sure it would... reply
hkt21 minutes ago | parent | prev[–] .. are you saying this from your tomb? reply
Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact Search:
來源:Hacker News:AI 熱帖 · news.ycombinator.com