Proton 的軟件工程 AI 宣言
Proton's AI manifesto for software engineering
Proton 的 CTO 發表面向軟件工程的 AI 宣言,主張組織投入 AI 轉型,並指出「Programming」已死,但工程與專業能力仍然重要。Hacker News 用戶質疑追求速度能否真正改善用戶體驗,並關注 AI 對軟件可靠性、安全、員工狀態及初級工程師培訓的影響。
Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin
Proton's AI manifesto for software engineering (proton.me) 21 points by doener9 hours ago | hide | past | favorite | 13 comments help
Dxtros28 minutes ago | next[–] Why is the bottom line of this to work faster? I understand there’s a fear about “being left behind.” Being faster won’t stop you from being left behind. Unique insights and deliberate REAL improvements that benefit users will keep you relevant. Think about your audience. Proton is uniquely positioned, not because of how fast it deploys. I pay proton for its privacy, security and separation from from large tech company’s dark practices. This manifesto from the Proton CTO is framed as an opinion piece, which is insane. As a CTO your opinion shapes your technical policy. I hope this is truly an opinion piece that employees are able to disagree with. This is an opinion on how to burn out your employees, chasing speed, which benefits your users in no way. It’s an opinion on how to cultivate a toxic environment that treats its employees like less than they are. It’s an opinion that feels so out of touch with what I pay for and what users care about. AI is a tool, that people should have the freedom to use when it actually helps them work. Otherwise it can actually make things worse and slower. It isn’t magical. Your employees aren’t robots treat them well. Or leave and vibe code piles of nothing really fast, if that’s your opinion. reply
mrinf1nity5 hours ago | prev | next[–] > “Programming” is dead. Engineering is not, nor is expertise. No, it isn't. I'm sorry but this coke-bender manifesto is hilarious. Proton actively maps user accounts (sysadmins just look in) to IP addresses, e-mails, and shuts down journalist accounts because governments ask them to. Use bittorrent for some Linux isos on their free service it'll DNS hijack your webpages to whine at you, aka they openly MITM you. > But it is past time to commit, as an organization, to the transformation that the moment requires Replace this guy with AI. reply
pacha30008 hours ago | prev | next[–] Made a great use of my weekend to end my business subscription to Proton. This is the last straw. reply
alex_suzuki1 hour ago | parent | next[–] My Proton Business subscription renews in February, and I'm on the fence. All I want is a privacy-focused (ideally EU-based) groupware... Email, Calendar and some Shared Cloud Storage. I don't want Proton to move fast, I just want them to keep doing what I thought they were doing, and do that well. Fastmail has been mentioned multiple times, but they only do email and calendar (good for them!). But after reading all about what Yen's been saying, I'm considering switching anyway and swapping Cloud Storage for a NAS. reply
littlecranky678 hours ago | parent | prev | next[–] What do you use as alternative? I came from Google Workspace and Office365, they are horrible. And I don't think Microsoft and Google have a different stance on AI than Proton. reply
shinryuu6 hours ago | root | parent | next[–] There are some suggestions here https://www.privacyguides.org/en/tools/ reply
littlecranky676 hours ago | root | parent | next[–] Yeah I guess I stay with proton. I use drive, vpn, email (own domains), meet and their password manager. Seems I'd have to use individual providers for each of those, and manage a multitude of subscriptions. reply
rlvesco78 hours ago | prev | next[–] "This is not the death of expertise. The LLM is fast. You are slow, but you carry with you a lifetime of experience, judgment calls, and understanding." 1) Does expertise atrophy if you are just a human-in-the-poop (I mean loop) for an extended time period? 2) How do junior engineers develop the so-called expertise if they have not gone through all the steps and suffered repeatedly? On the privacy and security side: 1) Using AI to create apps seems to make them more vibey, less reliable and less secure ... at the same time AI has the ability to find bugs better than before. Feels like a paradox that will get resolved at some point in the future, but at the moment software "feels" like it's getting less reliable. 2) If I were a government, I'd be super excited to inject backdoors and subtle vulnerabilities via AI into proton. To use AI without a good strategy into a privacy organization is like having the fox guard the hen house. reply
littlecranky678 hours ago | parent | next[–] > 1) Does expertise atrophy if you are just a human-in-the-loop Well I guess you use the same technique as for muscle athrophy. I sit all day at work and and drive to places using machines, so my body athrophies due to lack of movement. We built gyms where you go to to fight that athrophy. And we invented jogging and hiking where you go to places without the intent to actually travel somewhere. Same thing applies: You will have to program without AI on projects, that are not your real end product to keep your skills in training. > 2) How do junior engineers develop the so-called expertise if they have not gone through all the steps and suffered repeatedly? Same as above. The training + education will take longer, we will have to create training products for the juniors to practice and gain experience. The products will not necessarily be used in production, but should only be seen as sparring rigs. reply
spottedmarley6 hours ago | prev | next[–] After ~10 years with ProtonMail I have gone back to hosting my own email and, with the help of Claude, I now have the email setup I've always wanted. I'm actually kinda glad now to have been forced to finally solve email for myself so, thanks ProtonMail, it was a good run. reply
overflowy6 hours ago | prev | next[–] Ah yes, let yourself become a meat proxy, embrace it, love it, you will surely become better this way! reply
asphodele6 hours ago | prev[–] It seems nothing is safe from enshittification. reply
littlecranky675 hours ago | parent[–] How has proton enshittified? Honest question as I am a yearly proton business subscriber. reply
Consider applying for YC's Winter 2027 batch! Applications are open till November 2. Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact Search:
來源:Hacker News:AI 熱帖 · news.ycombinator.com