跳到正文
DEV Community· Tony·· 5 小時前AI 評分42

5 款 AI 虛擬佈置工具檔案大小比較:最小檔案並非最差

I Compared File Sizes of 5 AI Staging Tools. The Smallest File Wasn't the Worst One.

AI 導讀

作者以同一張照片比較 5 款 AI 虛擬佈置工具,指出檔案大小不能單獨反映編碼細節,應以每像素位元數(bpp)比較。Collov 的 131.5 KB 輸出為 1.07 MP、1.01 bpp;DoVirtualStaging 的 102–159 KB 輸出為 0.81–1.25 bpp,小檔案不等於壓縮較差。

正文

A 131 KB file and a 3.8 MB file came out of the same input photo, from tools in the same category. Which one is better compressed?

The wrong answer is "the smaller one." The also wrong answer is "the bigger one, obviously it has more detail." Both are wrong because neither number means anything on its own. Here is the measurement that actually tells you something, and what it exposed about my own product.

The setup: one photo, five tools

On November 13, 2026, I ran one photo through four commercial virtual staging tools. I also ran it through a fifth, DoVirtualStaging, because it kept coming up whenever I searched for one-time pricing. Every tool got the same source file: a Pexels room photo at 7,360 × 4,912 — 36.15 megapixels, 2,150.9 KB.

Same input matters. If each tool gets a different photo, every difference in the output is confounded. With one source, every difference is the tool.

I did not trust the specs on the pricing pages. I opened every downloaded file locally and read its actual dimensions and byte count.

What the files actually contained

Tool Output Megapixels Size Bits per pixel % of source area
Source photo 7,360 × 4,912 36.15 2,150.9 KB 0.49 100%
VirtualStaging.AI 7,360 × 4,912 36.15 3,830.1 KB 0.87 100%
StageHQ "full size" 2,496 × 1,664 4.15 727.2 KB 1.43 11.5%
StageHQ "MLS size" 1,536 × 1,024 1.57 320.7 KB 1.67 4.3%
AI HomeDesign 1,729 × 1,157 2.00 125.9 KB 0.52 5.5%
Collov "1080P" 1,264 × 844 1.07 131.5 KB 1.01 3.0%
DoVirtualStaging 1,248 × 832 1.04 102–159 KB 0.81–1.25 2.9%

The number you should actually read

File size is a product of two independent things: how many pixels there are, and how many bits each pixel got. One number tells you nothing about the other.

The useful metric is bits per pixel:

bpp = (file size in bytes × 8) / (width × height)

Higher bpp means each pixel carries more encoding detail. Lower means the encoder compressed harder. Crucially, bpp is scale-independent — a 1 MP file and a 36 MP file become comparable.

Now the table reads completely differently:

  • Collov's 131 KB is not a crushed image. At 1.07 MP it is 1.01 bpp — higher than the 36 MP source photo's 0.49. It is a small canvas, not an aggressive compression. Those are different failures with different fixes.
  • DoVirtualStaging's 102–159 KB is in the same league at 0.81–1.25 bpp. I expected the small file to look bad next to a 3.8 MB one. The division says the encoder is fine.
  • VirtualStaging.AI's 3.83 MB is real. Its bpp went from 0.49 to 0.87 while keeping all 36.15 MP. That is not an upsample of a small render — something was genuinely re-encoded at higher quality across the full frame.

I got this wrong on the first pass. I saw "2 MB in, 3.8 MB out" and wrote it up as interpolation. The bpp calculation disproved me.

Three claims the specs would not have told you

"Full size" is whichever size the vendor picks. StageHQ's default "full size" download is 2,496 × 1,664 — 4.15 MP, 11.5% of the source. Its "MLS size" is 1,536 × 1,024. The actual 4K option is a separate paid credit, not part of that four-button menu. Nothing is dishonest about this; the label just means "largest one we give you by default."

"1080P" does not mean 1920 pixels wide. Collov's 1080P download is 1,264 × 844. It is a name, not a measurement.

The biggest file and the smallest file can both be correct. VirtualStaging.AI kept every pixel because a print board may need them. The 1.04 MP default from DoVirtualStaging is sized for an MLS listing feed. Those are different jobs. The mistake is pretending one is universally better.

The part where my own product loses

The default output from DoVirtualStaging is 1,248 × 832. VirtualStaging.AI's is 7,360 × 4,912. That is a 34.7× difference in pixel count. No bpp arithmetic rescues it. If you zoom in on an MLS listing or print a flyer, you will see it.

There is a 4K export — 4,992 × 3,328, one export per photo per day, no credit and no render consumed. I weighed three of those exports: 4.0 to 5.4 MB as JPEG. But that is an upsample of the 1,248 × 832 render. Those pixels are interpolated, not recovered. The 36-megapixel detail from the source photo is gone and no export menu brings it back. If the job needs that, pay a tool that keeps it.

Stating the limitation is not modesty here. It is the whole point of publishing measurements: the numbers that hurt are the ones that prove the method is honest.

What a benchmark like this cannot prove

One photo, one run per tool, one day. This tells you what each tool produced for this image. It does not tell you the average pass rate, how a paid tier differs, or whether a different room would produce the same ranking.

It also cannot tell you whether a model preserved the architecture. That is a separate test — file bytes say nothing about whether a window moved. For that, count the window panes in the original and the render, measure the door against a known 2.03 m height, and trace the ceiling line to the frame edge. On DoVirtualStaging — a pay-once AI virtual staging software — that constraint is called Structure-lock, and a render that moves a wall is treated as a failure rather than a style choice. But the three checks work on any tool, that one included.

Reproduce it

You do not need my conclusion. You need the arithmetic:

  1. Get one source photo. Use the same one for every tool.
  2. Download the default output — not the marketing example, not the paid tier.
  3. Read the dimensions and byte count from the actual file.
  4. Divide. Do not compare kilobytes.
  5. Write down what the tool did not preserve. That is the part most likely to cost you later.

Prices were read from vendors' own pricing pages on November 12, 2026; files were measured from downloads completed November 13, 2026. Both change. When they do, the method still works.


All numbers came from downloading the files and reading them locally, not from any spec sheet. That includes the row where DoVirtualStaging loses by thirty-five times the pixels.

來源:DEV Community · dev.to