Meta Muse 購物實測:AI 智能體結帳時多出 5 美元
I Let Meta Muse Do My Shopping. The AI Agent Tried to Upcharge Me
Amanda Smith 實測 Meta 的 AI 智能體 Muse 購物,發現它能推薦秋季衣物,但結帳時出現 $5 差額。Muse 無法解釋差額,皮帶也未出現在購物車;作者最後仍透過 Muse 購買了皮帶。
Fall is my favorite season for fashion: the earthy colors, oversized blazers, cozy sweaters, neck scarves and corduroy pants. I always have grand visions for my wardrobe once there’s a chill in the air, but I end up running out in yoga pants and a cute knit.
According to my wardrobe, there are only two temperatures: hot and cold. I want to change that this season. After a rough couple of months of IVF and loss, I’m in my glow-up, self-care season.
New hair, new skincare, new workouts and, yes, a new wardrobe. Because I don’t have time to scour the internet for cute fall finds, I’m tasking Meta’s new AI agent, Muse, for the job. If cookies can follow me everywhere online, surely I can use that to my advantage and turn an AI agent into my personal shopper.
More from CNET
Muse launched earlier this month, pegged as a personal AI agent that doesn’t just answer questions but also does the work. It’s built for the billions of people on Facebook who have no technical experience. It can open a browser, fill out forms and negotiate on your behalf — asking for approval before sensitive actions such as making a purchase or sending an email.
AI agents still feel a little mysterious, so let’s test out Muse’s tricks.
Getting set up
My goal was to use Muse as my personal shopper by getting it to review my bookmarks, Instagram searches and followers to run a full style analysis of what I’m interested in, and then find pieces for my wardrobe.
Given that I spend more time on my phone than on my laptop, I opted for the mobile version of Muse. Because it’s a Meta product, it already has access to a lot of information about me via my Instagram, Facebook and Threads accounts.
I downloaded Muse from Meta on the App Store and logged in with my account. It offered a few caveats and suggested checking for mistakes or unexpected actions.
Meta/Screenshot by CNETI turned on my notifications for Muse so I wouldn’t miss anything. I decided not to connect Gmail or Google Calendar, as it didn’t really need that information to shop. I didn’t tinker too much with the prompt settings or goals before I started, but it’s worth having a look at the footer section, especially if you’re stuck for ideas.
Some interesting use cases are finding tickets for events this weekend, building a workout plan with the gear you own, hunting down a product on Facebook Marketplace and taking a photo of your meal for the calories and macros.
For this task, I went straight to the chat function and instructed it with this first prompt: “I want you to be my personal shopper and assemble my fall wardrobe with a few new pieces. Review my Instagram searches and followers to run a style and color analysis. I definitely want corduroy pants, neck scarves and slides.”
Here’s the initial response:
Meta/Screenshot by CNETI told Muse my sizes and preferences, then it started its search. It browsed for a few minutes while I went about my day. I started getting notifications, so I asked if it was still searching and told it to let me know when it was done.
It responded with “Still going — scarves and slides are done (sent those above), and the corduroy pants + knits search is mid-browse, currently checking J.Crew. I’ll message you as soon as the full wardrobe edit is ready.”
A few minutes later, it was ready. Here’s what the result looked like:
Meta/Screenshot by CNETWhat was cool about Muse was that it gave me ideas that I hadn’t thought of, like the belt I saw in one of the pictures, worn by the model who was sporting a sweater Muse had suggested I buy. I asked Muse for the next steps.
Meta/Screenshot by CNETI checked out each link, then gave Muse feedback to hone the search, including asking it to find cheaper versions of some of its suggestions, and to find me some black loafers and the belt I liked.
The agent ran into a capture issue with TikTok, but I took control of the browser so it didn’t get stuck. What was cool was being able to reply directly to each message so it could run various searches simultaneously.
I narrowed it down to two products it found – the belt and the corduroy pants. Muse asked whether I wanted to buy them now or build outfits around them. I opted for the first.
Meta/Screenshot by CNETI was still a little unsure about the products, so I found a video of that creator I liked and asked Muse to find me belts like that. Finding the right look and price required some back-and-forth chatting, but it was worth the effort.
To test out the complete Muse experience, I ordered the belt and saved the other links for later. It gave me a few payment options.
Meta/Screenshot by CNETGiven that this was my first AI agent purchase, it involved more questions than usual. I wanted it to do everything automatically, so I backtracked a step and added my shipping address and connected my bank account in Link, which I should’ve done at the start. You’ll only need to do this once.
I was a little nervous about linking my details, but I followed the prompts and verified my address in Link. You’ll receive a confirmation email of the account connection.
Meta/Screenshot by CNETBefore it processed the payment, it confirmed the total with shipping. I asked if there was any way to remove that shipping fee, but I would’ve had to pay $99 (Muse usage is free with a token quota, then ranges from $20 to $100 per month), which I didn’t want to do, so I told Muse to proceed.
It gave me the final total, but there was a $5 discrepancy.
Meta/Screenshot by CNETI took control of the browser, because it kept coming up as $42, to check for any hidden fees, but there weren’t any. I kept asking it to “try again.”
Meta/Screenshot by CNETBut it couldn’t do it, and it couldn’t give me an answer.
I took over the browser to close out the sale, but the belt wasn’t even in the shopping cart. Muse’s “advice”? Open Uniqlo, add it to the cart, and check out. Very helpful.
Well, that was anticlimactic.
The verdict on Muse as a personal shopper
I went ahead and bought the belt through Muse anyway, just for the AI agent experience. That part took all of 2 minutes to complete, but it wasn’t the time saved that I was interested in; it was the fact that Muse wasn’t able to complete it accurately automatically. (Meta didn’t immediately respond to a request for comment on why this happened.)
While Muse got me 95% of the way there, inspiring a new fall piece, it tried to charge $5 more without any reason. Sneaky, Meta.
Amanda Smith
Contributor
Amanda Smith is a freelance journalist and writer. She reports on culture, society, human interest and technology. Her stories hold a mirror to society, reflecting both its malaise and its beauty. Amanda's work has been published in National Geographic, The Guardian, Business Insider, Vice, News Corp, Singapore Airlines, Travel + Leisure, and Food & Wine. Amanda is an Australian living in the cultural center of gravity that is New York City. See full bio
The Latest from Amanda
來源:CNET · cnet.com