跳到正文
Hacker News:AI 熱帖·· 9 天前AI 評分30

AI 訓練是否值得摧毀書籍?

Are we just going to ignore that books are destroyed for AI?

AI 導讀

Hacker News 用戶討論 AI 訓練相關的書籍掃描與銷毀,焦點是掃描後是否應保留紙本。有人指出,少量印刷的學術書籍可能因此失傳;也有人認為,被銷毀的多是原本已準備棄置的書籍,並討論版權規則對公開掃描版本的限制。

正文

Image 1Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

Are we just going to ignore that books are destroyed for AI? (forbes.com/sites/maryroeloffs) 24 points by nyxtom2 hours ago | hide | past | favorite | 24 comments help Image 2Kim_Bruning58 minutes ago | next[–] The better practice would have been to download an existing archive. They did. They got sued to pieces over it. So this is the only legal avenue. reply Image 3pfdietz2 hours ago | prev | next[–] Yes, we are, because it's a non-problem. reply Image 4ChrisArchitect13 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Story from August OP; Various discussions: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49330742 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49068738 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49310725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49383026 reply Image 5Lithuanian2 hours ago | prev | next[–] Does it matter much? Books are digital anyway and every book has a copy of itself somewhere in the world. It's not like something irreplaceable is being destroyed. reply Image 6TFNA1 hour ago | parent | next[–] These projects are trying to crawl the whole ISBN space. I know for a fact from my own academic discipline that there are ISBN-issued books containing some useful scholarship that were printed in a print run of as little as 50 or 100 copies, and for various reasons most of those copies are basically lost now to digital-archiving efforts. If someone is destroying a remaining copy before shadow-library scanners can get to it, that is indeed lamentable. reply Image 7brainwad1 hour ago | root | parent | next[–] The solution would seem to be not to blame the AI companies for using their property as they wish, but to loosen copyright law so they could release their scanned versions to the public and/or resell their books after scanning them. Or force publishers to print on demand any work they wish to keep the copyrights for. reply Image 8TFNA1 hour ago | root | parent | next[–] Why do you think they want to release the scanned version? Having a model trained on exclusive content not available to competitors is a competitive advantage. Selling the books afterwards would be additional work and not guaranteed to bring any profit or even any significant reimbursement. A company is likely to find simply pulping the books to be the most cost-effective solutions. reply Image 9brainwad56 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] Goodwill. It would instantly end this line of attack against them, for little cost. The only reason they don't do it now is that it's illegal. reply Image 10TFNA3 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] I think you are overestimating the amount of people outraged by this, and so overestimating a business's need to placate them. Among popular discontent against AI companies, this is very far down the list. Image 11rolph1 hour ago | parent | prev | next[–] if you have familiarity with books, you will know that they are also unofficial repositories. a book may be published, but after purchase it may be annotated, dog eared, and exposed to a work environment, basically imbued with information beyond its original manifest. reply Image 12rc51501 hour ago | prev | next[–] what can anyone do individually to do anything about it? until regulation happens at a governmental level, there's not a whole ton the average joe schmoe can do about it. reply Image 13p_l1 hour ago | parent | next[–] Technically it's regulation that forces that. Anyone remembers when Google Books project might have provided a digital library after painstakingly non-destructively scanning books? reply Image 14vegnus56 minutes ago | prev | next[–] Is it true that examples of the books in question would be some operators manual for a 1970s toaster? reply Image 15m4rtink1 hour ago | prev | next[–] All books are sacred. Anyone who destroys books is a criminal and should be punished hard, ideally to make an example, preventing more books from being destroyed. reply Image 16nyxtom2 hours ago | prev | next[–] I know this is old but it seems that we've somehow moved on from the fact that we're in a modern Alexandria moment where rare text is being destroyed reply Image 17pfdietz2 hours ago | parent | next[–] I doubt any rare valuable book is being destroyed. If a book were valuable, it would make sense to scan it non-destructively. This is especially the case for old rare books that are long out of copyright; the copyright motivation for not keeping the original copy around does not exist. The books being destroyed as so worthless they're bought in bulk and were destined for junking anyway, like the 600 million books that are destroyed each year just in the US. At least as pulp they can contribute something of slight value. Here's a way these old supposed valuable books can get a new life. Go wild! Prices start at $12.99 per linear foot. This clearly demonstrates the value society assigns to these precious rectangular prisms of inked cellulose. https://booksbythefoot.com/ I have a sneaking suspicion the whole tempest-in-a-teapot was astroturfed by publishers who were miffed at the courts looking favorably on scanning for AI training. reply Image 18unpleasurable1 hour ago | root | parent | next[–] The construction of roads can use about 45,000 books per mile. reply Image 19jon1281 hour ago | root | parent | prev | next[–] If I were a not so good guy running an AI company and I got my hands on a valuable book, I would scan the book and destroy the paper copy. This way, others won't scan that knowledge for themselves and would have to come to my company to get access to the knowledge and only crumbs of that knowledge at my discretion. Yes there are people who have this psychology. reply Image 20metalman1 hour ago | prev | next[–] We are ignoring that AI is bieng used to commit genocide on the Pastinian people, what are a few books? reply Image 21damnitbuilds1 hour ago | parent | next[–] If you can defend people who kidnap children and rape festival-goers, what are a few less Hamas terrorists ? reply Image 22TRiG_Ireland56 minutes ago | root | parent | next[–] If you can defend people who use armed drones to shoot down young children fleeing the remains of their bombed school, what are a few less IDF terrorists? reply Image 23TacticalCoder1 hour ago | parent | prev | next[–] Then in the interest of things being balanced, I want to also hear what we are ignoring about the islamist republic of Iran slaughtering 30 000 of its own people, because they were protesting, unarmed, in the streets of Teheran. Certainly you have something to say about that too? And what about 1200 civilians getting slaughtered at a music festival on october 7th: what's your take on that? P.S: as a sidenote, what does your comment have to do with AI destroying books? reply Image 24damnitbuilds1 hour ago | prev[–] Anthropic are evil motherfuckers. Don't use them, don't let your boss make you use them. Local models will win in the end. reply Image 25barbazoo1 hour ago | parent[–] A model being local doesn't mean it wasn't trained on books that were subsequently destroyed, does it? reply Image 26 Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact Search:

來源:Hacker News:AI 熱帖 · news.ycombinator.com