跳到正文
CNET· Ajay Kumar·· 10 天前AI 評分63

Apple HomeView 評測:屏幕出色,仍無法理順混亂的智能家居

Apple HomeView Review: Lovely Display, Won’t Fix Your Jumbled Smart Home

AI 導讀

CNET 作者實測 Apple HomeView 約兩星期,認為它適合深度使用 Apple 生態系統的家庭,卻未能解決跨品牌智能家居裝置的整合問題。它配備 7 吋屏幕和 Face ID 個人化設定,並能整合 Hue 等 Matter 裝置,但作者未能連接 Lockin Veno Go 智能鎖及 Eufy 設備。售價為 $299,屏幕尺寸和第三方應用支援亦有限。

正文

Apple’s new HomeView isn’t new. There are plenty of smart displays with voice assistants that incorporate speakers, cameras, video calling and other functionality. Our favorites include Amazon’s Echo Show 8 and Echo Show 11 and Google’s Nest Hub (2nd Gen) and Nest Hub Max. What makes the HomeView compelling is that it’s Apple’s first device designed specifically for Apple’s HomeKit ecosystem, and it also lets you manage calendars, grocery lists and more with the extra privacy of personalized Face ID profiles. 

I spent two weeks putting the HomeView to the test, integrating it into my smart home in hopes it could pick up where my vintage 2023 Amazon Echo Show 8 left off. I used it to manage my household’s Apple calendars, play music, control a small army of smart home devices, create grocery lists and set reminders. Apple’s debut display is impressive, but you should know a few things before making HomeView your smart home centerpiece. 

HomeView with the Snoopy face on a table.

The HomeView has a series of delightful faces, including an animated Snoopy one. / Ajay Kumar/CNET

Best smart display for Apple and HomeKit

Apple HomeView

8.0

  • Attractive, premium design and small footprint for desktop use
  • Works well with integrating HomeKit and Matter smart home devices
  • Personalized Face ID locked profiles for up to six family members
  • Robust room-filling audio
  • On the more expensive side at $299
  • Apple's walled garden may restrict some apps you use
  • Wall mount loses more powerful speakers while costing the same
  • Screen felt a little small at times

Get it now

If you’re well integrated into Apple’s ecosystem, have HomeKit devices or are planning on picking any of the new Home Collection accessories, the HomeView is going to be worth it despite the $299 entry price. Android users or split device households may want to stick with Echo and Nest.

An attractive screen, premium build and solid audio 

Apple HomeView side profile.
The HomeView design is premium and attractive, with a smaller side profile than many other smart displays.Ajay Kumar/CNET

This is officially my second look at the HomeView. I snuck a peek at Apple’s buzzy Welcome Home event, but didn’t get much time to admire it. I’ve now spent roughly two weeks with the HomeView sitting on my desk next to my aging Amazon Echo Show 8 (2023), and the difference between the two is significant, though a direct comparison isn’t completely fair.  

More from CNET

CNET’s Tyler Lacoma notes that the newer 8.7-inch Echo Show 8 is a more capable, redesigned model, with an HD display, faster chip, spatial audio, a 13-megapixel camera and Alex Plus, so that’ll be a much closer match, and you’ll get similar performance from both in terms of the screen quality and audio. 

The design feels premium right out of the box, with a rounded, egg-like body, a tiltable 4:3 screen sprouting from it, a speaker grille along the bottom, and a soft, Apple-branded, non-slip white bottom. It’s weighty and solid-feeling, which makes it feel like the $299 smart display you’re paying for.   

The 7-inch 1,088×1,088-pixel Liquid Retina IPS display is bright and vivid, with viewing angles that put my washed-out Echo Show 8 (2023) to shame. Scrolling is quick and responsive, as you’d expect from newer hardware powered by the Apple A18 chip, while my older Show 8 feels sluggish. 

An Apple HomeView device on a wooden table. The screen shows a child blowing a bubble.Ajay Kumar/CNET

There’s also a 12-megapixel Center Stage camera and impressively loud audio with two full-range drivers, a down-firing woofer and dual force-canceling passive radiators. My wife and I both loved using it to listen to music in our large living room. The audio quality is just as good as the HomePod Mini 2, and the sound remained full even with bassier metal. At one point I even thought the music was coming from our Samsung Music Frame, rather than the HomeView. 

While I probably won’t replace my Bose SoundLink Max for regular listening, it’s good enough that your ears won’t be offended by the audio and even in bigger rooms, the music can fill the room, and you have the option of connecting one or more HomeView, HomePod, HomePod Mini or AirPlay speakers for multi-room audio. Note that if you get the wall-mounted HomeView, you get only two custom drivers with audio tuned more for wall placement, meaning no passive radiators or woofer.   

A delightful desktop and bedside companion, but at times I wanted a bigger screen

Ajay Kumar/CNET

The HomeView offers a range of customizable clock faces that show you time, date, timers and weather, plus options to add new ones and create your own modular face with custom widgets. In some ways, it reminds me of a super-sized Apple Watch, giving you immediate information at a glance, but you can also use it as a family photo album, which is what my wife did with the one in the living room (naturally, it’s exclusively pictures of our cats). I also found the animated Snoopy watchface delightful, with fun animations that families with kids will particularly enjoy. 

As a desk companion, the footprint works perfectly on my desk, taking up much less space because the speaker body elevates it off the desk. It also fits well on my nightstand, and the adjustability lets me tilt the screen so it’s immediately visible when I’m lying in bed, making it easier to check notifications. At my bedside, the integrated ambient light sensor and True Tone were a nice touch, automatically adjusting brightness and color temperature throughout the day and toning it down when it was time for bed without me needing to fiddle with anything. 

The calendar and Home dashboard were two of my biggest use cases while I was plugging away at my desk. Connecting my iCloud calendar for both work and personal email immediately populated it with upcoming events and meetings.

More significantly, my wife could also set up a profile to create a shared calendar populated with chosen shared events. This is an underrated feature for me because, on our Android-powered Apolosign calendar, both our workplaces block out time when we connect our work accounts, so I never know when she has an upcoming meeting or an important call I shouldn’t interrupt. 

Ajay Kumar/CNET

In this case, it seems like Apple’s more robust privacy settings came through in a clutch because the connection was approved where Android-powered smart calendars have generally been rejected.

Using HomeView as a smart dashboard was generally a good experience, though there are some caveats I’ll touch on below. I connected it to my Matter-compatible Hue hub and had it import the lights and settings directly; with around 18 lamps and bulbs, I could control them right at my desk, including dimming, ambient lighting, color, and more. 

This is actually something I’ve been trying to hack together using my Elgato Stream Deck (not to be confused with a Steam Deck) by creating shortcuts on the buttons that control my Hue lights. The HomeView made that much simpler, giving me the controls I wanted at my fingertips.    

Apple needs a larger screen size option for living rooms and kitchens 

However, I first noticed the issues with the 7-inch screen in the smart home dashboard. Up close on my desk, the controls work fine, but the 4:3 display feels awkward in terms of size, since it usually shows only two columns of devices and requires you to scroll down to reach the others. On a larger Echo Show, I can have a good chunk of my devices appear at the same time. 

The 7-inch screen is also notably smaller than the 8.7-inch Echo Show 8 and much smaller than the 10-inch Nest Hub Max and the Echo Show line that’s been steadily growing in size, with options that reach up to 21 inches. We’ve reached the point where smart displays are becoming wall-mounted, or fridge-mounted, home hubs, giving you and your entire family access to calendar events while also doubling as a secondary TV for streaming shows and videos.

HomeView wall mounted
The wall-mounted HomeView looks good, but the 7-inch screen is hard to see from across a room, even if it adjusts itself.Ajay Kumar/CNET

It was in the living room where I felt the downsides of the smaller 7-inch screen the most. I could ask Siri to pull up what was coming on my calendar, but actually viewing the calendar and events on the screen required me to get closer than I would have on a larger screen. The HomeView adjusts the interface based on your distance from the display; up close at my desk, I get more information at a glance, while farther away I may see fewer things, but they’re more visible. 

It’s still not the same as having a bigger screen, though. Say what you will about the 21.5-inch Apolosign, but I can see the events and calendar from quite a distance, which isn’t the case with the HomeView. This is especially true if you want to use the HomeView to view different security camera feeds. It supports up to nine, dividing the screen up into squares so you can view them all at the same time. Apple demonstrated up to four feeds for me, which is fine if you have the HomeView wall-mounted as a security hub and you’re standing in front of it, but pushing beyond that will likely just make you squint. 

Apple and HomeKit users will find a lot to like, but Apple’s walled garden can be restrictive  

Ajay Kumar/CNET

It’s no surprise that HomeView works best with other Apple devices and HomeKit-compatible products. It’s designed to work as a companion to your iPhone or iPad, so it supports AirPlay and Continuity, making it a seamless experience to hand off FaceTime calls, Safari tabs and other media between devices. 

There’s no App Store on the HomeView itself, and no way to add apps directly to the screen. This isn’t an exclusive list, but what you get right now are FaceTime, Find My, Calendar, Messages, Live Activities, Alarms and Timers, Intercom, Safari, and Reminders. Basically all the key iPhone apps, plus Apple TV, News, Podcasts, Audiobooks, and I was able to have Audible and Spotify surface on it as well. 

This is the kind of curated experience you might get on a CarPlay dashboard, not the free-range options of an iPad: What you have on the HomeView is what you get. If there’s a killer app you want, or if you want to use Google Calendar or Chrome, even though you have the app on your iPhone, it won’t be available on the HomeView as of this writing. I also didn’t see a way to add services like Amazon Music, Tidal, SiriusXM, Prime Video, Netflix, and other major music and streaming apps to the HomeView. An Apple representative told me that there’s currently no comprehensive list of which third-party apps and services are supported on the HomeView.

Privacy first, integration later 

The HomeView is notably more cautious about privacy than many other smart displays we’ve tested at CNET, which is what you want when your entire family is going to use a camera. Each HomeView user (up to six) has a personalized profile, home screen and content that only they can access after Face ID unlocks it. I confirmed this after checking my wife’s calendar to see what upcoming events she had. I couldn’t do it until she came and checked it herself (the workaround is to set up a shared calendar as I mentioned earlier). 

Ajay Kumar/CNET

Recognition is also quite good and quick. The HomeView was fairly accurate about switching from one family member to another, though it sometimes got a little confused if we were standing close to each other. In most cases, it seems to prioritize the first person it detects, but it’ll unlock things like private messages only if the paired iPhone is nearby. Certain things like music, smart home controls and weather stay accessible across users

Intercom is also an underrated feature. I didn’t expect to find it useful. From the Home app or any HomeView, you can leave a voice message on all devices, just like a school intercom system. I was able to call my wife from our front door while she was in our living room and have her hear the message, while normally we need to shout down the hall. I imagine this is even more helpful if you have a multi-story home and kids, rather than just a modest apartment with three disobedient cats. 

Not even Apple can fix a fragmented smart home ecosystem, but it’s a worthy try  

Ajay Kumar/CNET

When I first saw HomeView in action, the most compelling prospect was its ability to manage all my third-party smart home devices and calendars without endless individual app setups. That’s the selling point, but the reality is mixed. 

With Matter-compatible smart home accessories like my Hue hub and Hue lights, it worked mostly perfectly and exactly as advertised. I was able to find my Hue hub, add all the various Hue lamps and lights across the different rooms of my house, and it actually carried it over correctly with my existing settings, modes, and integrations. It also works with Apple’s adaptive lighting, automatically shifting the color temperature of your lights throughout the day. With Hue, this is the experience I was looking for, and if it had worked just as seamlessly across my other smart home devices, I would have been thrilled. 

Ajay Kumar/CNET

However, trying to connect my Matter-compatible Lockin Veno Go via the Home app didn’t work even though it should be supported. It recognized the device and tried to connect, but it just couldn’t pull it off. My Anker Eufy app, which controls my other smart lock, smart doorbell and a variety of home security cameras, also failed to connect even though the app confirmed HomeKit support and the connection seemed to sync initially before failing. 

Ajay Kumar/CNET

Ultimately, I still haven’t been able to get either connected, even though they both work just fine with my Echo devices and are integrated with Alexa Plus. While Apple is still looking into the issue on my behalf, I suspect the problem comes down to something in the handshake between the third-party app and Apple’s Home app. Once again, the fragmented smart home ecosystem rears its ugly head, and even Apple doesn’t have a perfect fix. 

Ajay Kumar/CNET

That brings me to Siri AI, which is Apple’s attempt to use Apple Intelligence to take on rival AI-powered voice assistants by offering better integration with things like emails, reminders, and notifications, and more contextual and conversational capabilities. It works well and is much better than plain old Siri at adjusting to the conversation, such as adding or removing items from an open grocery list, managing timers and pulling things from your calendar. 

It also worked fine for controlling my Hue lights, but I hit an integration wall with several other smart devices, including the home security devices I couldn’t connect and my Dreo ceiling fans, which claim to support Siri voice commands, but I couldn’t find any way to connect them. It also tends to take a beat longer than Alexa at carrying out a command. It’s not dramatic, but the extra second or two is noticeable. 

Ajay Kumar/CNET

Generally, my experience has been that Matter-supported devices and Philips Hue work great, but if you’re using more “budget” smart home devices and appliances, the integration is hit or miss compared with Alexa, which supports just about anything and the kitchen sink. I’ve more or less never had a smart home device, no matter how no-name or off-brand, reject an Alexa connection, while HomeKit usually belongs to a more exclusive club. 

Who should get the HomeView? 

Apple HomeView

If you’re well integrated into Apple’s ecosystem, have HomeKit devices or are planning on picking any of the new Home Collection accessories, the HomeView is worth it, even with a $299 entry price. As Apple’s first smart display, it functions better and more smoothly than an equivalent $200 Amazon Echo Show 8 or $100 Nest Hub (2nd Gen), though you’re paying the Apple premium. You also have another choice to make: the stand or mount version. I’ve put together a pretty extensive guide on the different HomeView models you can buy and what a wired install might cost you. 

But if you’re more like me, with dozens of different smart home devices across brands, and you’re a household that uses a mix of Apple and Android devices, the HomeView is a tougher sell. The Home dashboard can handle some key smart home integrations, but it’s not the all-in-one solution I was hoping for, partly because the smart home ecosystem is so fragmented. If you’re an Android user who uses smart displays for streaming and/or is on a budget, you’d be better served by a more affordable Echo or Nest smart display. 

來源:CNET · cnet.com